Why Reinstatement Cost updates need more than inflation
.jpg)
The RICS professional standard Reinstatement cost assessment of buildings (3rd edition) sets out a three-year cycle. A full reinstatement cost assessment (RCA) with a site inspection comes first. The sum insured is then adjusted each year for inflation, followed by a major review and reassessment every third year, or sooner if the building is substantially altered.
The annual update is where values most often drift. It is quick and cheap to apply a broad inflation index, but RICS itself notes that “inflation indexation is not the only variable”. Over two years of indexing, the gap between the sum insured and the real rebuild cost can grow and leave owners under-insured without knowing it.
What inflation indexing misses:
- Location: Construction costs vary from region to region and from city to city. The gap between local and national prices shifts as each market heats up or cools down.
- Building type: Rates for offices, industrial, residential and leisure buildings don't all move together. A single headline index applies one movement to all of them.
- The building itself: extensions, plant replacement, PV, and new cladding all change the reinstatement cost. An index can't see any of them.
A recent example that Kingswood completed demonstrated the above. We updated the RCAs for a portfolio of regional offices. Instead of applying a single index, we benchmarked each asset against current cost data for its building type and local market. Across most of the portfolio values moved by between -3% and +4%. Two assets in northern cities rose by over 15%, even though neither building had changed. Local cost data showed that construction prices in those two markets had moved significantly ahead of inflation. If the RCAs had simply been indexed, both assets would have been insured for around 12-13% less than it would cost to rebuild them.
It matters because under-insurance is rarely noticed until a claim is made. If the sum insured is too low, the average clause can reduce the settlement in proportion to the shortfall. That applies to partial losses as well as total ones.
Over-insurance has a cost too. Where values have fallen, which happened on two assets in the same portfolio, owners pay premiums on cover they don't need.
We recommend the following approach:
- An annual desktop update that benchmarks each asset against current local cost data for its building type, not just a broad inflationary uplift.
- A check for physical changes with the managing agent, such as new plant, PV or extensions.
- A full reassessment every three years in line with RICS, or sooner after major works, to confirm areas, specification and the reinstatement period.
If your RCAs haven't been reviewed in this way, let's speak.
Let us help.
Are you an investor or lender in Real Estate and need support? We would love to help. Use the form below to get in touch with the team or contact us on admin@kingswoodrea.com.